This is actually what’s happening behind the scenes, to keep the overdrive and non-overdrive DPMs (damage per minute) in line with each other. This is because the cooling time on its own is not enough to offset the difference. So e.g. a 25% overdrive might actually have closer to 35% more heat.
You’re overlooking the “long-term” aspect. This is a more appropriate analogy:
- Gun 1 has 60 round magazine, X damage per shot and shoots 5 bullets per second (so it can fire continuously for 12 seconds). Magazine reload time is 4 seconds.
- Gun 2 also has 60 round magazine, X damage per shot and shoots 10 bullets per second (so it can fire continuously for 6 seconds). Magazine reload time is 10 seconds.
Both guns fire 60 bullets over 12+4=6+10 seconds.
If there’s any advantage to overdrive, then it’s the degree to which a particular wave can be played with short intense bursts rather than long continuous stretches of fire. Which is really an alternative perspective on this:
I’d rather not have overdrive on all weapons. If there really is a benefit to overdrive, then there is no reason not to use it all the time. I’d prefer it if all manual weapons reverted back to their old (slow) firing rates, and overdrive would bring them back to their current (non-overdrive) values. So you’re balancing “automatic weapons without overdrive” against “manual weapons + overdrive”. This means that for someone who can’t use overdrive effectively (e.g. newcomers), the manual weapons would clearly be a worse choice. But I can live with that.
P.S. Alternatively, we could increase the overdrive to something ridiculous e.g. +100%, but make heat increase disproportionately so that you could only use it for 1-2 seconds at most (and afterwards you’d have to suffer extended downtime). That would make it appropriate only for certain situations (e.g. stopping player-homing enemies, or preventing an enemy from leaving the screen, or getting to a key drop faster) rather than a general-purpose crutch.